Showing posts with label pesticides. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pesticides. Show all posts

Saturday, June 15, 2013

Data Review

I hear many times that the "data" has not be scrutinized or analyzed at the Health Department,
The strange thing is that i did, back in July of 2012.
Not that it was a perfect analysis, but i compared all wells tested, wells showing the presence of pesticides with those not showing pesticides present.
What is this you say? show me?
Here is a general overview:

All well results since 2008 to 10/2012:
  House Built Well depth well distance pool Onsite   Current land layout Past Land use
     
Average 1959 248 34   2 2
Max 2008 1100 200   6 6
Min 1700 30 0   1 1
count 1001 168 112 94 646 639
median 1962 195 25     2 1

The numbers for past land use and land layout are as follows:
ID # Current Land Past Land Use
1 Flat undeveloped
2 gentle slope Forest
3 moderate slope Animal Farm
4 steep slope Farm
5 Rolling Hills Landscaping buisness
6 Hilly Industrial


Data for the next categories are until July 2012, not Oct 2012
wells with pesticides found:
  House Built Well depth well distance pool Onsite   Current land layout Past Land use
     
Average 1952 210 26   2 1
Max 2007 800 81   4 4
Min 1730 30 0   0 0
count 149 35 34 11 72 69
median 1960 120 20     2 1

Wells without pesticides found:
  House Built Well depth well distance pool Onsite   Current land layout Past Land use
     
Average 1959 260 36   2 1
Max 2008 1100 200   6 4
Min 1735 30 0   0 0
count 640 102 66 47 325 300
median 1963 220 25     2 1
there are slight differences, but not statistically significant not do the difference correspond to changes in the use of the pesticides.

Sadly this does not show any way of determining if a home might have an issue or not - it varies by factors that we cannot determine, of course if someone would develop a time machine, we could see what was happening to cause these problems.  i do not think it would be that surprising.

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

And then there is good news...

in this grouping of the same magazine that keeps me informed of so much, they report that certain chemicals in Honey breaks down toxins and particularly pesticides.
Honey works in bees when they eat it, will it work in us?
probably, since the action is a chemical (enzymatic) one!

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Pesticide variance revisited

For the past 4 years, i have remarked that i have not seen significant variance in pesticide levels in wells where it was found.
At first because the variance in one well in two test done 11 years apart was insignificant.
Then there were 8 wells in which in DEEP was taking samples quarterly and except in 2 cases of potential collector error (one was acknowledged and the other not)  there was not a significant variance.
In the last part of sample collection this year 2 wells were repeated - one had nothing showing in 2009 and had dieldren over the action level in 2012.  The other had trace levels a few years ago and not only was dieldren over the action level, there was chlordane showing up as well.
One occurrence is an anomaly, twice something to be concerned about.
I believe that the Health Department will recommend continued testing.

Sunday, December 30, 2012

first year of testing

The goal was 750 and thing were started late.
The person collecting samples was not hired until the middle of March.
The final total?  751.
the person hired was able to do 707 of those samples, while the inspectors added 44.
This was in spite of the snow storm and hurricane, so it was a job well done.

But people are not interested in numbers, but rather results.

I think the most significant thing uncovered was extremely high chlordane levels in the mid west portion of Stamford, far away from all the tauted "sources". 
5 samples over US EPA MCLs and none relatable to the dump or the arboretum.
19% of the sample had some level of pesticide in them.
5% were over the action limits set by the State of CT.
The issue with pesticides and their affect on our lives may be more complex than simple carcinogens,
a recent study indicated there may be effects of the immune system and although it would be virtually impossible to study, there is thoughts that chromosome damage might be generational.

The numbers in the drinking water still pale in my view to the constant exposure that all of us have to all the newer agents used to control insects and the older ones still hanging around.

Sunday, December 2, 2012

Swan Song

In 7 days, i will no longer be the "chemist" at the Stamford Health Department.
There may be even fewer posts in this area after that.
I have allowed my RS in Connecticut to lapse as of November 30th, which shows you just how commited i am to leaving this feild.
I have kept my ACS (American Chemical Society) membership because chemistry is a very diverse feild and is involved in every part of our lives, whether it be using man-made items or natural products.

The lab at the Health Department will no longer be offering any metals testing - no iron or manganese, copper, arsenic, calcium, magnesium, sodium, potassium, zinc or lead.
At least until they hire someone new who is interested in these things (read what this says about the current person, who is strictly clinical).

This bathers me, but there are other labs that offer such testing, the lab has that list.

This bothers me because lead and copper still top my list of the most prevelant metals and the reasons are fairly clear - old pipes, old well pumps or pumps that failed and could not be extracted from the well, there is not natural lead and copper in this area.
Arsenic worries me because even though only 3 wells have been found at the action limit,  Arsenic was used extensively in many products and it remains a significant hazard.
Although a person has said they found mercury in their well, thay have not shared any results and that makes it hearsay and i personally think it is just some one wanting to make trouble.  No mercury has shown up in any tests submitted to me.
Uranium, one of those "natural" products has shown up in a number of wells and this does concern me.  We never could test for this, but other labs can.
Manganese is one of those discoloration metals that has the potential to be dangerous to your health at high levels.  It exists in many wells.
VOCs (Volitale Organic Compounds, think solvents) have been found in insignificant quantities (mostly due to chlorine use) throughout Stamford.
Pesticides, the big concern, have shown to be all over and very persistant in the environment.  Political and executive descions will prety much keep this as a Stamford problem, even though it is very clear to me that it is found anywhere that had some sort of usuage when the pesticide, particularly dieldren and chlordane) where legal to use.
People continue to use pesticides on lawns with great abandon, so more problems will show in the future.
This of course seems to only be a concern as far as wells are concerned.  Everything is treatable and i will continue to say there is more risk in all the other exposures that we have in eveeryday life, than form the well water.

Thursday, November 29, 2012

this is not a feel good post...

For many years i have thought of the pieces that i am going to write now.
I will probably do this over time, but I have started it this day in November

The air we breath,
the food we eat,
the water we drink.
The earth we live on,
the homes we build.
through so many reasons, that i can not enumerate them all...
are not safe.

And yet, the problems that are expounded on
and the solutions that are brought, seem to be less than i could imagine.

Taking care of ourselves,
eat right (but is there really a way to eat right?), exercise, do things in moderation, do not stress out, but everything conspires against this.
To much sugar, too little, to much fat, but only of a certain kind.
Protein only, no protein.
No pasta, but eat like a Mediterranean (without pasta?)
Vegan, vegetarian, carnivore is anything "best"?

water treated, water tainted - what is really bad and what is economically convenient?

And so i can go on, but you get the gist of it.

Is something "organic" because it has no pesticides?
What about the plastic it is wrapped in?  Is that safe and the truck spewing diesel fuel as it carries the "organic" produce to market, that does not taint the product?
 (celery seems to get the most pesticide, as an aside, but some of the things i have seen come from the packaging is far worse, yes really!)

The pesticides that are used and then get into the water we drink in nanogram quantities. 
Is it better that we ate them (pounds probably) as part of our daily vegetable intake over the years?

The hysteria the the US EPA made over Radon, extrapolated from persons exposed to huge quantities in uranium mines.

But chlorine and its by products is not a problem,even though we are exposed to large quantities in the water we drink and the cleaners and the laundry.

But chlorine is used to kill bacteria, all of them, even the good ones...but the bad ones still keep coming at the restaurant, from a sneeze, from our own kitchens....

The fear is real - we have done a lot to ourselves (or rather those we let process our food), but the blame game is an illusion.
Each of us, everyday, no matter how careful we seem to be or want to be are exposed to quantities of carcinogens and toxins and bacteria to will kill us.
Much of it is "natural", much we made to protect ourselves from something we considered worse.

We have to live with this understanding that it is no ones fault and everyone fault..

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

transforming old farms into housing with wells is a bad idea.


more on pesticides
I have been tearing apart the data we have collected from all the well testing,
there are things i "see" as the data goes in that i have to prove by sorting and compiling the data.
That is part of why the Nitrate post was important, because the supposed link between Nitrate levels and pesticides is in the very fabric of current State of Connecticut thinking.
However, this does not mean the reason why that thinking exists is wrong.
The idea that old agricultural areas are to blame, i believe still holds water.
There are many old farm areas that have now become suburbs and this is what i address today.
Data was collected (as best that we could) on past uses of a property.
The entire dataset now has close to 1000 test results,
the dataset of property that used to be on farm land is smaller, but over my own designated limit of 50 wells.
Of all the wells tested, 19.1% of the wells have some pesticide present,
7.74% have pesticides over action limit
From homes that were built in areas that were farms:
26.23% of these wells have some pesticide present
14.75% have pesticides over the action limit.
When looking at the GIS map of this information, it should be noted that only a portion of the old farm area is effected, most of the area is not.
This would indicate that a significant portion (not the only) is from old farm dump sites.

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Confusion, detection limits and action levels

It is time for me to "go" there.
The article was in the Advocate (Stamford newspaper) talking about detection limits and how tests before 2011 were not any good because they could not "see" trace amounts of the pesticides everyone was worrying about.
The reality is many tests done by several labs were reported down to a detection limit that was as sensitive as it could be, many were not and it depended on the lab.
A discussion on this can be found at the following link.
It is confusing.
There were labs which were simply taking peoples money and doing a test which was only a screening test.
There were other labs who would not report down to the detection limits.
Now tho, there is another wrinkle - the state lab will no longer report anything below the current action level.
There maybe politics involved since they used to do this.
If the DEEP uses the state lab, then one could expect to see some where around 5% of the wells with reportable amounts of pesticides in CT.
In Stamford, we have been looking for any amount detectable and that level runs about 19%.
This of course will mean that "pesticides" are a "Stamford" problem and not a big deal.
I have seen (and have some of them in my possession) reports from other towns with pesticides in wells that are both above the action levels and below.
These wells are not necessarily near Stamford.
Is 19 or 29% unacceptable and 5% is?
Those are questions people need to ask and it does get confusing.

Monday, July 9, 2012

Pesticides and personal experience

many years ago before i was a chemist, i had a cat.
The cat was Siamese and was unusual the way Siamese cats often are.
He caught, one spring 4 baby quail and brought them to us unharmed.
We decided to raise them and built a large cage on the side of the yard.
The quail lived several years until a neighbor decided to spray their entire yard for insects.
Being in the 1960's - Chlordane was the probable agent and maybe mixed with dieldren.
The quailed died immediately after the spraying, along with a Horn Toad that liked our rock garden and a Red eared terrapin (turtle).
I did not understand all of it at that time, but it left an impression that i would not use pesticides when ever possible.
Fast forward to 2012 and a discussion with a state person asking for the original copies of test results from 1990.
The strange thing about this is that things have changed.
In 1990,the current method used for detection was not widely used.
The best Gas Chromatography used capillary tubes and the best detection level i saw was 0.5 ppb -
the current action level for chlordane is 0.3 ppb and 0.03 for dieldren and most levels are below 0.5 ppb.
There was an experimental method (at the time) that reached 0.1 ppb,
but the reality is you are comparing apples and squash - not even the same classification.

How we learn

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

on the other hand...

below the merit parkway, in older homes, with no builder dumps, with no city dump...
the presence of pesticides was 25%.
This is clear support for the idea that they can be found in any well, any where and have more to do with how we used and discarded the pesticides when they were still legal.
This has been my statement all along.
Now it is up to the other places with wells and surburbia to start testing.

Monday, May 7, 2012

alternate explainations

based on information that i had from quarterly tests from the CT DEP (now DEEP), i had postulated that a significant rain after an exteneded low rain period might give false negative results for pesticides.
There were logical reasons for this, particularly if the contamination was coming from a "deep" source.
Samples taken 2 weeks ago, during the 5 day period after heavy rains that i was concerned with, gave several samples with both dieldren and chlordane. 
One would have been sufficient to disprove the theory.
Before this i only had one sample that fit the criteria. 
What is most sad about this is that it now sheds a bad light on HOW the samples were collected.
The DEP had made errors previously (and corrected them) and i was hoping this was not the case, but it appears it probably is the case and that error in sample handling might cause more issues than rain.

Thursday, February 23, 2012

more pieces of a puzzle

while things seem to be very chaotic around me, i still search for information and answers...

Understanding the “why” of pesticides appearing in wells



The initial issue is dieldren and chlordane’s persistence in the environment.

Chlordane does degrade, but obvious takes many years to do so, but dieldren seems to last longer.

Both pesticides are considered water insoluble, with the solubility of dieldrin being 0.186 ppm and chlordane’s being 0.032 ppm.

The first thing to consider; dieldrin is slightly more soluble that chlordane and would move a bit better in ground water.

More to consider; a study performed in 1992[1] indicated that chlordane would become more soluble, significantly (> 400 ppm) more soluble in ground water with a high organic carbon content (such as septic systems).

Does dieldrin do the same thing?  There are no studies that I found.

What I do have is the information of the quarterly tests done on wells with Connecticut Department of Energy & Environmental Protection showing 2 cases where chlordane shows up in the well water test after 30 days of heavy rains.  This does not occur with dieldrin.

Chlordane also becomes undetectable when the rainfall amounts are not great.



The second issue is presence of chlordane in sediment from Long Island Sound (LIS) presented in a study from 2007[2].  The end discussion is that there is continued chlordane input into LIS, even though it is decreasing.  This means that most of the chlordane has “washed out” of the soils where it might influence well water.  There was no references to dieldrin.

Now this secind bit of information might have implications for the Lobster die off?
No - it clear says that levels have not changed since 1977 - chlordane is not the problem...



[1] Environmental Science & Technology, 1992, 26, 2234-2239, Partitioning Behavior and the Mobility of Chlordane in Groundwater.
[2] Environmental Science & Technology, 2007, 41, 7723-7729, Persistent Chlordane Concentrations in Long island Sound Sediment:  Implications from Chlordane, 210Pb, and 137Cs Profiles

Monday, November 28, 2011

The Dieldren controversy

Why is this a controversy at all?
Because the agencies which are suppose to regulate such things have left it open, not closed.
Some where in the 1970's the US EPA decided that Dieldren, Aldrin and the chemical similar compounds were bad.  They restricted the use of the organophosphates so they could not be used for agricultural products.
They also declared that the were carcinogens of a type.
In 1987 they banned all use of dieldren, but they did NOT regulate dieldren nor did they create a maximum contaminant level (MCL) for its presence in drinking water.
By now you are saying, "Huh?"
Well so am i.  This of cource leads many others to question what was going on.
The US EPA is still on record as declaring dieldren a carcinogen, but they simply do not back it up.
now others start asessing the issue:
In 1987, the US Environmental Protection Agency(EPA) classified aldrin and dieldrin as category B2 carcinogens, i.e. probablehuman carcinogens, based largely on the increase in liver tumors in mice fedeither organochlorine insecticide. At that date, the relevant epidemiology wasdeemed inadequate to influence the cancer risk assessment.
There is more
There is no conclusive evidence that aldrin ordieldrin cause cancer in humans. Aldrin and dieldrin have shown to cause livercancer in mice. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) hasdetermined that aldrin and dieldrin are not classifiable as to humancarcinogenicity. The EPA has determined that aldrin and dieldrin are probablehuman carcinogens.
Okay so what is the big deal?
The US EPA has again failed.
With Radon they threw a lot of money to get all the states on board the issue, even thought there was evidence that this was not as big a deal as they made it. (National Science foundation really link the cancer to a serious issue for those who smoke).  They did not do this with the pesticide, thus we have controversy.


Friday, November 4, 2011

Well water Summary

This is a revision and update of something i did back in June, when the old fresnel glasses were what i had.
There were errors and this is the first revision.  there will be more.  I have all the data and there are sevral question i am asked.
One is about radon and is it really correct oplace it at the top?  I have supporting data that i can not use because i do not have a "hard copy" of the results from someone who tests and did a comparrison that ranks very similar to my information (a bit down from my numbers, but very significant).

The following is a summarization of water tests that have been submitted to or performed by the Stamford Health Department Lab and the various issues and problems that have been found.  We used simple criteria of having more than 25 tests results (0.5% of wells in Stamford).   

The following tables are an overview.  The same evaluation parameters are used for each item in this table.  Samples with treatment are not included. Multiple tests from one location only show the highest results. Tests for pesticides which were performed by the one lab not certified to do so and were using unapproved methods were removed (7 addresses).  This also includes older test where the detection limit was limited to 0.1ug/L (51 addresses, 12 repeated by newer tests). 

TABLE 1a – Health Dangers related to cancer

item
Average in number tested
Highest value found
Number of addresses recorded
Descriptions
Percentages
Radon
35,316 pCi/L
555,000 pCi/L
99
At or Above  RL
 (5,000 pCi/L)
At or Above CT average
(7,000 pCi/L)
75.76%
72.73%
Uranium
0.020 mg/L
0.77 mg/L
46
present
At or Above MCL
(0.03 mg/L)
56.52%
6.52%
Arsenic
0.0022 mg/L
.010 mg/L
134
present
At or Above MCL (0.010 mg/L)
43.28%
2.24%
Dieldren
0.0258 ug/L
1.30 ug/L
499
present
At or Above AL
(0.03 ug/L)
15.03%
9.02%
Chlordane
0.0416 ug/L
2.90 ug/L
499
At or Above AL
(0.3 ug/L)
At or Above MCL
(2.0 ug/L)
9.62% 
4.21%
0.20%
Other pesticides
0.0035 ug/L
0.32 ug/L
499
present
AT or Above MCL (various)
4.01%
0.00%
Total pesticides
0.054 ug/L
2.90 ug/L
499
Present
At or Above MCL
19.04%
9.62%


Each of these items have some indication to a risk for cancer, the following is a discussion on risk by other agencies and studies.  Dieldren is seen as being the most controversial item as far a cancer risk, with many studies NOT implicating it.  While there is some controversy concerning Radon in water, there is a direct link to Radon in air and lung cancer and a general rule as far as how much water borne radon contributes to air radon (every 10,000 pCi/L in the water, contributes 1.0 pCi/m3 in the air)


Arsenic - Skin damage or problems with circulatory systems, and may have increased risk of getting cancer[1]

Chlordane - Liver or nervous system problems; increased risk of cancer[2]

Dieldren - In 1987, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) classified aldrin and dieldrin as category B2 carcinogens, i.e. probable human carcinogens, based largely on the increase in liver tumors in mice fed either organochlorine insecticide. At that date, the relevant epidemiology was deemed inadequate to influence the cancer risk assessment.[3]
There is no conclusive evidence that aldrin or dieldrin cause cancer in humans. Aldrin and dieldrin have shown to cause liver cancer in mice. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) has determined that aldrin and dieldrin are not classifiable as to human carcinogenicity. The EPA has determined that aldrin and dieldrin are probable human carcinogens.[4]

Radon - The radon in your water supply poses an inhalation risk and an ingestion risk. Research has shown that your risk of lung cancer from breathing radon in air is much larger than your risk of stomach cancer from swallowing water with radon in it. Most of your risk from radon in water comes from radon released into the air when water is used for showering and other household purposes.[5]

Uranium - Increased risk of cancer, kidney toxicity[6]

 The probable sources for each of these items are from.

Arsenic – Erosion of natural deposits; runoff from orchards; leeching from pressure treated wood (1940 to 2004, especially since 1970), runoff from glass and electric production wastes.

Chlordane – Residue of banned termiticide

Dieldren – Residue of banned insecticide, breakdown product of aldrin (also a banned pesticide used in agriculture for root vegetables)

Radon – Erosion form natural deposits

Uranium – Erosion from natural deposits


[2] http://water.epa.gov/drink/contaminants/index.cfm
[3] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10555138
[4] http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaqs/tf.asp?id=316&tid=56
[5] http://www.epa.gov/radon/pubs/citguide.html#radonwater
[6] http://water.epa.gov/drink/contaminants/index.cfm

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

The revision of an old well statue


From the state of CT on well testing and report.

This is a revision of Section 19a-37 of the public health code.

I believe it was an attempt to clear up language concerning reporting laboratory testing of water for home sales.

I read it through a couple of times and my eyes hurt.

I received some advice on how to review it and not to try to do it in my head.

Okay that was good advice; it meant that they read this blog and know this is legalese, not math.

It still hurt my head.

The attempt was, I believe, to say exactly who needed to report what to whom and under what circumstance.

For those of you who are scratching your head, there was something in the public health code that said, in effect, if you sell your house, the water must be tested 6 months before or 6 months after the sale and the results must be reported to the local director of health and while one lab did this (not including me), no other lab in the state did it.
This one says it must be reported to both the director of health and to the state by the lab doing the test.
There is more. a lot more and it begins to restrict power of how legislation can do and what health directors can and can not do.
The one that disturbed me was one limiting the health director from requiring pesticide tests unless there was a dump or nitrite levels were over 10(my plain langauge, not theirs)...this bothers me on many fronts.  pesticides do have to do with fertilizer, but not always, they have something to do with dumps, but not always.  I feels that they are trying to take control of something that shuld not be taken control of in the way they are.
There is a lot more.
This is the link to the whole giberish:
http://www.cga.ct.gov/2011/ACT/PA/2011PA-00242-R00HB-06618-PA.htm

Monday, October 24, 2011

pesticide variance again

Again i reviewed data from the state and my weather data and relized that i have answered my question from the last post on this subject many times...
there are 2 sources for every well with a septic system!
Once a well has pesticides in it, the septic system does also and since around here the septic is a major source of recharge for the well, you have very rapidly another source...not fun.
Now what does this mean?  When the weather is very dry - you will not get recharge from the septic.
From the data, i found a particularly bad time August 2010...

Sunday, October 16, 2011

more questions pesticide variance

So why are pesticides found in wells?
This begs more questions on variance.
Save for what is put into a septic system or buried in a "disposal pit" or land fill or injected into 5 foot holes around for termite control, how does something get into ground water and then into a well?
We know CT has a decent frost line in winter, 1 to 3 feet, 3 being less likely now a days.
We know ground water in CT generally flows North to south because of the glaiers and the lay of the land.
If pesticide contamination reached a fairly deep level of porous rock, it should maintain a fairly steady level, decreasing over time, if there is a single source.
If it comes from more surface sources, it wll be affected by frozen ground and rainfall.
If it comes from multiple sources, then there sould be a variance over time with overlapping "plumes".

What is it, is the question.

Thursday, October 13, 2011

pestcide variance - an attempt to view


I had a brainstorm last night – it was concerning how pesticides vary in the amount in a well over time and how I could view that as a fact and what might the issues be.

The source is the testing done by the DEP (now DEEP) on filters they installed in Stamford on wells which tested positive for pesticides.

They did the testing quarterly and I have been recording the info, but really did not know what to do with it…until now.

Then I began reviewing the data and realized that I had not critically looked at the data – if I had I would have noted some issues.

There are times when the “raw” (without or before the filter) sample had no pesticides, but the sample after the first filter did.  Unless something happened and the filter was exposed to high (I mean above the boiling point of water) heat, pesticides should not have been released.  This means that samples were mislabeled or switched in the lab (it happens, you know, we are not perfect).  I could accept this and correct for it.  It almost meant that no one else looked at the information critically either.

I also, generally do not get a copy of the lab’s paperwork, only a summary report from DEP.  One time I did get the lab’s paperwork and the sample was not received at the lab at the proper “less than 6 C” and the lab had (rightfully so) a disclaimer about the results.

Additionally, the testing is done, by request, by the 508 method.  Now the reality about this method is that is identical to the 505 method except that it starts with a much larger sample volume.  I do not have a problem with this.

The final problem was not with the results, but with me.  As I have been struggling with my recovery, there are times that I make mistakes and do not enter thing properly (it is all about the eyes, all about the eyes).  I try to keep the paper work, but there are times that I lose it and file it in a pile.  There was something in this batch of numbers that I wanted to check and could not because I could not find the paperwork.  This of course is very frustrating, but what I have to deal with.

If variables such as temperature and rain and any other weather condition caused the variances then the difference between pesticide changes should be similar between the 4 homes reviewed.

They were not similar enough for me to say yes to this idea.

The other variables that i can think of are water usage, multiple contamination points or layers and soil type, this is information I do not have.


For your entertainment, the graphs I compared are included: